Montessori vs. Traditional Education
Sometimes it is easier to understand the differences between traditional forms of education and that of Montessori pedagogy when the two ideologies are placed in a side by side comparison.
Below is a chart that juxtaposes both with regard to the method of instruction, environment and the role of the teacher.
Traditional Classroom | Montessori Environment |
Child is led toward textbook-driven curriculum; pencil and paper, worksheets and dittos primary source instructional material dependence from adults
Adults are the main providers of learning, discipline, social problem solving |
Prepared kinesthetic materials with emphasis on conceptual understanding; incorporated control of error; specially developed reference materials
The Goal is to lead children toward independence, academically as well as through social problem solving |
Working and learning without emphasis on social development | Working and learning matched to the social development of the child |
Narrow, unit-driven curriculum | Unified, internationally developed curriculum |
Blanket approach to teaching – everyone doing the same thing at the same time | Education is set to each child’s academic individual academic level; subject choices made by student |
Block time, period lessons | Uninterrupted work cycles that allow the child to complete tasks before moving on to the next |
Single-graded classrooms | Multi-age classrooms |
Students passive, limited to desks; problematic transition times | Students active, softly conversing, with periods of spontaneous quiet; freedom to move |
Students fit mold of school, primarily designed for middle level achieving students | School meets needs of all students, from the academically gifted to the challenged |
Limitation on cooperative learning- students in direct competition with each other | Cooperative learning is encouraged; students willing to aid one another |
Product-focused report cards | Process-focused assessments, skills checklists, mastery benchmarks |
Environment is prepared for the teacher to be the sole and center of attention | Environment is prepared for the child; apparatus is systematically placed in accordance by the progression (difficulty) of the materials |
Teacher acts as dispenser of knowledge. Greater part of learning is presented, in auditory fashion, from the teacher; or read from text books | Teacher acts as facilitator of knowledge. Greater part of learning comes from child’s own discovery and work with the materials |
Instruction primarily dealt within units; no particular order, later to be tied into a whole concept | Instruction presented in the whole, in chronological fashion, then broken into parts |
Learn even more about the differences between Montessori vs. Traditional education here.